Reviewer Guidelines

1. Reviewer Role

Deskomvis relies on qualified peer reviewers to provide independent, confidential, critical, constructive, and academically grounded evaluation. Reviewer recommendations are advisory; final editorial decisions remain the responsibility of the Editor-in-Chief.

2. Reviewer Selection

Reviewers are selected based on relevant expertise, verifiable academic identity and affiliation, recent scholarly publication record, independence, absence of conflicts of interest, and ability to complete the review within the assigned period.

3. Confidentiality and Double-Blind Review

Manuscripts and review materials are confidential. Reviewers must not disclose, distribute, reproduce, quote, or use unpublished manuscript content for personal, scholarly, commercial, or competitive purposes and must not attempt to identify or contact the authors.

4. Artificial Intelligence Prohibition

The use of generative AI, AI assistants, or other AI-based systems in the peer-review process is prohibited. Reviewers must not use AI to read, summarize, analyze, assess, score, evaluate, draft comments on, rewrite comments on, or recommend a decision for a manuscript. Reviewers must not upload or transmit the manuscript or confidential review material to an AI system.

5. Conflict of Interest

Before accepting an assignment, reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict that could affect impartiality, including close collaboration, supervisory relationships, institutional relationships, financial interests, personal relationships, or direct competition relevant to the work.

6. Standard for a Substantive Review

An adequate review identifies specific scholarly issues, explains why they matter, and indicates a constructive direction for revision. Comments limited mainly to grammar, spelling, layout, or typography do not constitute a substantive peer review.

7. Core Review Criteria

  • relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope;
  • clarity and informativeness of the title, abstract, and keywords;
  • adequacy of the state of the art, research gap, originality or contribution, and research objective;
  • appropriateness and transparency of research design and method;
  • quality and integrity of evidence or research materials;
  • depth of analysis, synthesis, interpretation, and comparison with relevant current scholarship;
  • strength of the conclusion in relation to the research objective;
  • quality and currency of references;
  • ethical compliance and research-integrity concerns; and
  • clarity, coherence, and scholarly presentation.

8. Reviewer Comments

Comments should be manuscript-specific, evidence-based, respectful, concise, and actionable. Reviewers should avoid generic statements, dismissive language, coercive citation, unnecessary requests for self-citation, and demands that authors adopt a reviewer's preferred approach without scholarly justification.

9. Confidential Comments to the Editor

Confidential comments should be reserved for concerns such as suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, citation manipulation, image or data integrity, undisclosed conflicts, authorship problems, or serious scope concerns.

10. Review Submission and Deadline

Reviews must be completed through the Deskomvis OJS review workflow. The normal review period is up to 28 days per review round unless otherwise stated in the invitation.